STUDYING THE ARCHAEOLOGICAL MATERIAL - The study of metal

ARCHAEOMETALLURGY

Valérie Pichot
"It would be difficult and unwise to begin with an overview; let us approach the world of metallurgy in short stages." M. Eliade, Forgerons et alchimistes, Paris, Flammarion, revised and expanded, 1977, p. 20
Archaeometallurgy, sometimes also known as paleometallurgy, can be defined as being the archaeology of the remains of mining and metallurgical activities. As in many other fields, it is thanks to the conjunction of inputs from different disciplines that one can make sense of the various types of archaeological remains. The interpretation of archaeological remains connected to the production and working of metal (that is, to the different processes that make up the production line) is very often difficult. These remains are in general unspectacular and hard to recognise. In order to identify the type of metallurgic activity as well as the socio-technological organisation of a given site one must undertake very detailed and methodical observations. Archaeometallurgy intimately links archaeology and archaeometry and implies a constant dialogue between the two disciplines.
 
Production line : this term applies to the process of transformation of a material of whatever sort (vegetal, mineral, cultivated plant, metal) from its state as a raw material to its state as a finished product. Each line can be broken down into a certain number of steps or stages of the process. The means employed during each stage are taken into account, described and studied; this could be a question of tools, actions upon the material itself, energy sources as well as time frame and the location of activity. This concept of a production line is the basic tool of the archaeologist and the historian of technology.
 
Laboratory work : the observation of the microstructure of a metal requires the preparatory work of removing and preparing samples from the selected object. These objects could be items of refuse related to metal work such as slag, hammerscales etc. or semi-finished products like blooms and ingots or indeed finished products. These samples are prepared in the laboratory (fixed in resin, polished) in order to obtain a perfectly smooth surface. They are then examined under a special (metallographic) microscope.
cliquer pour agrandir cliquer pour agrandir
View through a metallographic microscope
(Slag from the bottom of a forge – Cricket Ground excavation) - Photos © CEAlex

The work of metallography springs from the field of material sciences and is built upon the knowledge obtained from research into contemporary and ancient materials. A metal retains within it certain information that can provide quite precise evidence of the thermo-mechanic history of the object—hammering, casting, reheating, hardening. These observations are complemented by analyses of the composition of the metal. The results, after interpretation, allow one to identify the processes involved in the forming of the object, to reconstruct the chain of manufacture and to evaluate the quality of the alloys and the technological know-how.

Archaeometallurgy in Alexandria

The archaeometric and archaeological study of metallurgical production lines aims to identify, through the numerous archaeological remains, the types of activity, the socio-technological organisation within the sites, as well as the spatio-temporal organisation of the traffic in products (raw material, semi-finished product, finished product) in Alexandria and its environs during the Graeco-Roman period. One of the major points of interest in undertaking this sort of study within Lower Egypt lies in the apparent lack of a metallurgy of extraction (i.e. mining) and the importance of metallurgy of transformation based upon imports and exchanges over the medium and long distance.
The importance of Alexandria as a centre of commercial and industrial activities in the Mediterranean world of the Hellenistic and Roman periods is unanimously recognised. Within the numerous activities that enlivened the capital of Egypt, metallurgical industries seem to have held an important place. Metal production in Alexandria is attested for the Ptolemaic and Roman periods within literary as well as some papyrological sources, and the birth of practical chemistry is traditionally situated in Alexandria during the Roman era. It is, never the less, difficult to understand fully these activities through archaeology.

Test sites
(the study of these sites is presently under way)

The sites of the former British Consulate and Cricket Ground

The study of the archaeological material uncovered on these two sites (excavated in 1996-97) attests, for the Hellenistic period, considerable metallurgical activity within which iron works seem to predominate. A large amount of forge refuse was unearthed and the preliminary observations of this scrap allow for the two sites to be differentiated. While on the Consulate site we seem to be in the presence of forges for removing impurities (bloomsmithing), the refuse of the Cricket Ground site presents features suggesting a forge for creating small objects. It is clear that only through metallographic analyses and then a review of site data will we be able to determine to which stages in the production line these remains belong. Given the close geographic proximity of these two sites, it is tempting to suggest a link between their activities. Indeed, it is entirely possible that the semi-finished products made on the Consulate site were used in the workshops of the Cricket site. However, this link can only be proved by bringing together the archaeological data and the archaeometric results. culot vu de dessus, cliquer pour agrandir
culot (coupe), cliquer pour agrandir
Above : Slag from the bottom of a forge (view from above and in section). Cricket Ground excavation
Photos © CEAlex
The large number of iron and bronze arrow heads, iron lance heels (which are still being restored) and lead sling shot discovered on the Cricket Ground site has, naturally, led us to imagine an armaments workshop at the site.
Arms of the Hellenistic era®
(Cricket Ground site) Bronze arrowheads and lead sling shot
Photos © CEAlex

But we could also be dealing with material salvaged by the craftsmen and stored with a view to its eventual re-use. It is important to remain cautious when interpreting this type of discovery. Here again the confrontation between archaeometry and archaeology is essential in order to avoid any hasty short cuts.

The metallurgy workshops of Marea :

Situated some 40km south-west of Alexandria on the shores of Lake Mariout, the site of Marea, an important port in antiquity, is central to our archaeometallurgy research project.

From the end of the 1970s, archaeological work undertaken at Marea revealed substantial installations from the Byzantine period (baths, oil or grain mill, storehouses etc.) that indicate intensive occupation of this port town in Late Antiquity.
Since 2003, the work of the CEAlex, on the peninsula situated some 100 metres to the north-east of the town, has concentrated upon the study of the organisation, evolution and environment of a large workshop quarter principally dedicated to metallurgy activities.

Until now, knowledge regarding the occupation of the Marea site has been limited to the Byzantine era between the 5th and 7th centuries AD. Excavations on the peninsula have revealed an important occupation at the end of the Hellenistic / beginning of the Roman period, as well as indications of a Hellenistic occupation from the 3rd century BC.

Link to Marea Island excavation


si vous êtes entré sur ce site par cette page, cliquer ici pour activer la fenêtre de navigation